Carpet & Tile by the Mile vs Floor Covering Warehouse: which for tile and stone flooring?
Both shops turn up as strong Connecticut options for tile and stone flooring, and picking between them comes down to how each earned its reputation rather than a simple ratings gap. Our methodology weighs review volume, recency, and sentiment alongside the raw star rating, which is where these two start to look different.
The differences that matter
- In-store tile selection. Carpet & Tile by the Mile explicitly stocks a broad tile range alongside carpet, vinyl and laminate so you can browse tile and stone options in person, while Floor Covering Warehouse's praise centers on carpet and hardwood examples without singling out tile inventory.
- Track record on durability. Floor Covering Warehouse has operated since 1934 and points to a documented case of flooring lasting 20+ years before the customer returned, a longevity signal that matters for tile and stone work meant to last decades.
- Review volume and confidence. Carpet & Tile by the Mile has 119 reviews and a high-confidence composite score of 88.7, versus 35 reviews and a medium-confidence 84 for Floor Covering Warehouse, so the first business's track record rests on a larger sample.
- Documented turnaround speed. Carpet & Tile by the Mile has specific fast-turnaround examples (one job done in three hours, another in under a week), while Floor Covering Warehouse's speed example is finishing a complex condo job ahead of a tight timeline.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Carpet & Tile by the Mile: 4.8 (119 reviews)
- Floor Covering Warehouse: 4.9 (35 reviews)
- Services
- Carpet & Tile by the Mile: laminate vinyl flooring, carpet installation, hardwood flooring, tile stone flooring
- Floor Covering Warehouse: laminate vinyl flooring, tile stone flooring, hardwood flooring, epoxy concrete flooring
- Best for browsing tile/stone samples
- Carpet & Tile by the Mile: Yes, wide in-showroom tile range alongside carpet, vinyl and laminate
- Floor Covering Warehouse: Selection is broad but praise doesn't call out tile specifically
- Best for long-term durability track record
- Carpet & Tile by the Mile: Not documented in reviews
- Floor Covering Warehouse: 20+ year installation history and a business operating since 1934
- Best for complex or tight-timeline jobs
- Carpet & Tile by the Mile: Fast turnaround documented (hours to under a week)
- Floor Covering Warehouse: Handled a complex condo job ahead of a tight deadline
- Verification
- Carpet & Tile by the Mile: Google-verified
- Floor Covering Warehouse: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Carpet & Tile by the Mile: 89
- Floor Covering Warehouse: 84
What reviewers say
Carpet & Tile by the Mile
Staff by name, Denise in particular, guide customers through material choice with patience and deliver samples for home review. Installation crews work fast, arrive on time, and leave the site clean; one job finished in three hours, another in under a week from purchase to completion.
The showroom stocks broad carpet, tile, vinyl and laminate ranges, making local shopping practical for multiple rooms. A restoration company notes consistent service across repeat flooring jobs. Repeat customers mention returning for additional projects and upcoming room work.
Floor Covering Warehouse
All recent reviews are four or five stars. Customers consistently praise the team's expertise and willingness to listen. Joy, Gregg, and Greg are named repeatedly for guiding buyers through material selection and ensuring installations meet exacting standards. One reviewer noted the crew finished a complex condo job ahead of a tight timeline. Another reported carpet and hardwood work that lasted 20 years, then returned for more. Clean worksites, punctual arrivals, and polished seams feature across praise; pricing is called fair by multiple buyers.
Which should you pick?
Pick Carpet & Tile by the Mile if
- You want to browse a wide in-store tile and stone selection before deciding
- You want the business with the larger, high-confidence review history (119 reviews)
- You need a fast, documented turnaround from purchase to installed floor
Pick Floor Covering Warehouse if
- You want a shop with a multi-decade track record (since 1934) and proof of tile/stone work lasting 20+ years
- You're comfortable with a smaller but very consistent review base (4.9 from 35 reviews, all recent reviews 4-5 stars)
- You have a complex job with a tight deadline and want a crew experienced at hitting it
Verdict
For a tile and stone job specifically, the deciding factor is whether you want to shop from a large in-store tile selection with a big, well-documented service history, or you'd rather lean on a business with nearly a century of operation and a proven multi-decade durability record. Carpet & Tile by the Mile fits the first case, backed by 119 reviews and high-confidence scoring plus explicit tile stock. Floor Covering Warehouse fits the second, trading a smaller review sample for a longevity story (since 1934, 20+ year installs) that speaks directly to how tile and stone floors hold up over time.
Need help choosing the right contractor?
Describe your flooring job and get quotes from qualified flooring contractor in Connecticut.
Your contact form submissions may be shared with partner providers who can perform the work, and we may earn a referral fee from those introductions. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published methodology and are not influenced by referral fees.
Common questions
- Which business has more reviews for tile and stone flooring work?
- Carpet & Tile by the Mile has 119 reviews versus 35 for Floor Covering Warehouse, giving it a larger sample and higher confidence rating in the comparison.
- Does either business specialize specifically in tile and stone?
- Neither is exclusively a tile and stone specialist. Carpet & Tile by the Mile stocks tile among carpet, vinyl and laminate in its showroom, while Floor Covering Warehouse's documented praise focuses more on carpet and hardwood, though both handle flooring installation broadly.
- Which business has a longer track record?
- Floor Covering Warehouse has operated since 1934 and cites a customer whose carpet and hardwood work lasted over 20 years before they returned for more.
- Which business finishes jobs faster?
- Carpet & Tile by the Mile has specific examples of a three-hour job and a full installation completed in under a week. Floor Covering Warehouse is noted for finishing a complex condo job ahead of a tight timeline.