Best flooring contractors in New London
This ranks the eight strongest flooring contractors in New London using our methodology, which weighs rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment rather than star rating alone. Most of these outfits cover the full range of flooring and related home improvement work, so the order reflects overall track record, not narrow specialization.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to flooring contractor, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tile America New London | 85 | 4.9 (37) | — | Tile selection & design guidance |
| 2 | MT Home Remodeling | 84 | 4.9 (42) | — | Full remodels with tight project management |
| 3 | T.J. Nelson Home Improvements | 66 | 5 (13) | — | Long track record, straightforward pricing |
| 4 | Quality Craft Home Enhancements LLC | 87 | 5 (49) | — | Fast turnaround handyman-style jobs |
| 5 | Brewster Home Improvement LLC | 80 | 5 (12) | — | Detail-oriented flooring & tile combo work |
| 6 | Yankee Remodeler of New London | 67 | 3.9 (21) | — | Small jobs alongside bigger projects |
| 7 | Rodgers Construction LLC | 59 | 5 (1) | — | Small residential renovation projects |
| 8 | Skinny Construction | 59 | 5 (1) | — | New provider, verify current scope |
Ranked picks
Tile America New London
Why it ranks first
Tile America pairs a deep showroom inventory across ceramic, porcelain, and natural stone with named design staff who walk customers through material choices and color coordination. With a 4.9 rating across 37 reviews and strong sentiment scores, it earns the top spot largely on the strength of consistent praise for its design consultation process.
Pros
- Named staff (Ellen Foley, Jamie, Shari Giancarlo, Sheri, Sherrilyn, Angela Dunford) get repeat callouts for patience and product knowledge
- Wide selection across tile types and specialty collections
- Strong design and color coordination help for bathroom and kitchen remodels
- Budget-conscious recommendations
Watch out: Verification confidence sits at medium, so confirm current inventory and lead times before finalizing a design plan.
Services: tile stone flooring, hardwood flooring, commercial flooring
MT Home Remodeling
Why it ranks second
MT Home Remodeling has the highest confidence rating on this list (high, from 42 reviews) and a 4.9 average built on praise for Thiago's hands-on involvement and the team's daily site cleanup. Recent work spans kitchen remodels with hardwood installation, decks, and structural jobs, making it a solid pick for larger flooring-plus-renovation projects.
Pros
- Owner Thiago directly involved in planning and execution
- Named project coordinator (Theylon) keeps communication consistent
- Daily cleanup and fair, transparent pricing
- On-time completion across a range of project types
Watch out: One older review flagged slow estimate turnaround on a time-sensitive job, though this hasn't recurred in recent feedback.
Services: hardwood flooring
T.J. Nelson Home Improvements
Why it ranks third
T.J. Nelson holds a perfect 5-star average across 13 reviews and a reputation built over many years in the New London area. Ted's transparent, contract-based pricing and reliable crew show up repeatedly in feedback on jobs from kitchens to roofing to decks.
Pros
- Perfect 5-star record across all reviews
- Transparent, contract-based pricing
- Handles complex work including load-bearing walls and full kitchen renovations
- Punctual, reliable delivery
Watch out: Review volume is low and recency scored at zero, so it's worth asking about current availability and recent project photos.
Services: hardwood flooring
Quality Craft Home Enhancements LLC
Why it ranks fourth
Quality Craft posts the highest composite score on this list (87.3, high confidence) on the back of 49 five-star reviews with zero recorded complaints. The same named technicians, Alejandro and Charlie, show up again and again for quick, well-communicated jobs, though the bulk of their work leans toward general handyman tasks rather than dedicated hardwood flooring installs.
Pros
- Quick scheduling, including short-notice availability
- Pre-arrival and completion updates with photos
- Punctual arrival and thorough cleanup
- Named technicians with repeat customers and consistent quality
Watch out: Their work skews toward handyman-scope jobs (fixtures, doors, small repairs) rather than large flooring installations, so confirm scope fit first.
Services: hardwood flooring
Brewster Home Improvement LLC
Why it ranks fifth
Brewster Home Improvement holds a perfect 5-star record across all 12 reviews, with Travis and Erica singled out for attention to detail on flooring, tile, and multi-room projects. Customers return for repeat work, a good sign for anyone planning a phased renovation.
Pros
- Consistent 5-star track record
- Named principals Travis and Erica known for responsiveness
- Track record spans flooring, tile, doors, windows, and room additions
- Clean, organized job sites with clear communication
Watch out: Review volume is on the smaller side (12), so ask for recent project references if you're planning a large-scale job.
Services: hardwood flooring, tile stone flooring
Yankee Remodeler of New London
Why it ranks sixth
Yankee Remodeler shows a mixed but improving picture: recent work, especially Mike Mahoney's kitchen and bathroom projects and a 6,000+ sq ft commercial conversion delivered on budget, points to solid craft from named crew members. The 3.9 rating reflects some older friction, but the last year of reviews leans toward reliability.
Pros
- Named tradespeople (Mike Mahoney, Pete Doherty, Keith, Floyd) with repeat clients
- Delivered a large commercial conversion on time and under budget
- Willing to take on small jobs (repairs, routed stools) at fair prices
- Recent reviews emphasize improved communication
Watch out: Some customers have reported slow follow-up on initial inquiries, so plan for extra lead time when first reaching out.
Services: commercial flooring, hardwood flooring
Rodgers Construction LLC
Why it ranks seventh
Rodgers Construction has just one review on record, but it's a strongly positive one describing Nate's attention to detail, fair pricing, and clean worksite habits across multiple projects. This is a low-confidence pick worth a direct conversation before committing to larger work.
Pros
- Reliable, direct communication
- Daily worksite cleanup
Watch out: Only one review is on record, so there isn't much of a track record to evaluate yet.
Services: commercial flooring, hardwood flooring
Skinny Construction
Why it ranks eighth
Skinny Construction has a single 5-star review and not enough data yet to build a confident sentiment read. It's included here for completeness on the New London flooring roster, but it's best approached with direct questions about experience and past work.
Pros
- Single review on record is a full 5 stars
Watch out: Very limited review history means there isn't yet a reliable pattern to judge consistency or service quality.
Services: hardwood flooring
The scoring behind this list
| Signal | Weight |
|---|---|
| Review sentiment | 28% |
| Google rating | 26% |
| Review volume | 20% |
| Profile completeness | 16% |
| Review recency | 10% |
Ranking data checked 2026-09-23 · Full methodology ›