Best flooring contractors in Middletown
This ranks the top 9 flooring contractors in Middletown by an earned composite score built from our methodology, covering concrete, epoxy, tile, marble, hardwood, and carpet work. Most of these outfits cover the full range of flooring services, so they're ranked together on one list rather than split by specialty.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to flooring contractor, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DiamondKote Concrete Resurfacing and Epoxy Flooring | 87 | 4.9 (62) | — | Concrete & epoxy floors |
| 2 | New Creation Tile and Marble LLC | 83 | 4.9 (44) | — | Kitchen & bath tile |
| 3 | Custom Hardwood Flooring Plus LLC | 70 | 4.7 (26) | — | Hardwood refinishing & stain matching |
| 4 | Custom Concrete Solutions | 69 | 5 (12) | — | Decorative & commercial concrete |
| 5 | Home Services at The Home Depot | 62 | 3 (2) | inexpensive | Order guidance via retail network |
| 6 | Lombardo&Son Ceramic tile&marble LLC | 59 | 5 (3) | — | Custom tile & stone detail work |
| 7 | Concrete Renovations Inc | 57 | 5 (1) | — | Epoxy system selection |
| 8 | Middletown Ceramic Tile Co | 48 | 4 (1) | — | Limited evidence, verify services first |
| 9 | Drummond's Carpet Cleaning | 22 | — | — | Carpet cleaning, unverified track record |
Ranked picks
DiamondKote Concrete Resurfacing and Epoxy Flooring
Why it ranks first
DiamondKote leads the pack with a 4.9 rating across 62 reviews and the highest composite score on this list. Owner Michael stays hands-on through every project, and reviewers consistently describe finishes that hold up for years without cracking or wear.
Pros
- Owner-operated with direct project oversight
- Finishes proven durable over a decade
- Transparent pricing with no hidden costs
- Strong prep work, including rebar and crack prevention
Services: epoxy concrete flooring, floor refinishing repair, commercial flooring, hardwood flooring
New Creation Tile and Marble LLC
Why it ranks second
New Creation Tile and Marble backs up a 4.9 rating from 44 reviews with high confidence in the data behind it. John and his crew are known for punctual arrivals, spotless worksites, and tile finishes that hold up on close inspection, especially in kitchen and bathroom installs.
Pros
- Punctual crews that often finish ahead of schedule
- Meticulous attention to detail on floor leveling and glass tile
- Daily site cleanup and respect for the home
- Clear communication from design through completion
Watch out: One recent cancellation and a billing scope dispute have come up, worth confirming project terms upfront.
Services: commercial flooring, tile stone flooring, hardwood flooring
Custom Hardwood Flooring Plus LLC
Why it ranks third
Custom Hardwood Flooring Plus holds a 4.7 rating from 26 reviews, with owner Nick's team covering hardwood, vinyl, carpet, and epoxy for both residential and commercial jobs. Recent reviews point to on-time completion and careful stain matching, a shift from some older feedback.
Pros
- Owner Nick directly handles customer concerns
- Matches stains across existing floors
- Works around tight timelines and weekends
- Handles both residential and commercial projects
Watch out: A few older reviews mention scheduling delays, though this hasn't recurred in more recent feedback.
Services: floor refinishing repair, commercial flooring, laminate vinyl flooring, hardwood flooring
Custom Concrete Solutions
Why it ranks fourth
Custom Concrete Solutions has a perfect 5.0 rating across 12 reviews, with Mike and Don's crew handling everything from residential basements to churches and multi-location fitness facilities. Reviewers point to daily progress updates and finishes that exceed expectations.
Pros
- Certified in five major coating systems, including EliteCrete and Retroplate
- Handles both decorative and large commercial installs
- Proactive scheduling with daily updates
- Established commercial clients like Anytime Fitness and churches
Watch out: Review volume is still modest, so it's worth asking for recent project references.
Services: epoxy concrete flooring, floor refinishing repair, hardwood flooring, commercial flooring
Home Services at The Home Depot
Why it ranks fifth
Home Services at The Home Depot operates through the retailer's service platform and is open 7 days a week, which suits homeowners who want the backing of a national brand. The review record is thin, with one strong experience around cabinet design guidance.
Pros
- Backed by the Home Depot network
- Open seven days a week
Watch out: Only two reviews on record, including a recent complaint about reaching the Middletown location by phone.
Services: carpet installation, laminate vinyl flooring, commercial flooring, hardwood flooring · Price: inexpensive
Lombardo&Son Ceramic tile&marble LLC
Why it ranks sixth
Lombardo&Son Ceramic tile&marble carries a 5.0 rating from a small base of 3 reviews, with Joe Lombardo doing the work himself. Feedback highlights master-level tile craftsmanship and a willingness to walk homeowners through cost breakdowns.
Pros
- Master-level tile and stone craftsmanship
- Punctual and reliable scheduling
Watch out: Review count is low, so the track record here is still building.
Services: tile stone flooring, hardwood flooring
Concrete Renovations Inc
Why it ranks seventh
Concrete Renovations Inc has just one review on record, a five-star account crediting Pat with thoughtful epoxy system selection and fair pricing. It's a limited sample, but the single data point is a strong one.
Pros
- Responsive to customer needs
- Competitive pricing on epoxy systems
Watch out: Only one review is available, so there isn't much history to judge consistency.
Services: epoxy concrete flooring, hardwood flooring, floor refinishing repair
Middletown Ceramic Tile Co
Why it ranks eighth
Middletown Ceramic Tile Co shows a single review from six years ago, and the details don't clearly line up with flooring work. Its listed website references appliance repair rather than tile installation.
Watch out: Confirm current services directly before booking, since the available review doesn't match the listed category.
Services: hardwood flooring, laminate vinyl flooring, tile stone flooring
Drummond's Carpet Cleaning
Why it ranks ninth
Drummond's Carpet Cleaning has no reviews yet on record, so there isn't enough data to speak to recent customer experience one way or the other.
Watch out: No review history is available yet, so ask directly about recent work before hiring.
Services: hardwood flooring, carpet installation
The scoring behind this list
| Signal | Weight |
|---|---|
| Review sentiment | 28% |
| Google rating | 26% |
| Review volume | 20% |
| Profile completeness | 16% |
| Review recency | 10% |
Ranking data checked 2026-09-23 · Full methodology ›