Best flooring contractors in Middletown
Ten Middletown flooring contractors, ranked by an earned composite score built from ratings, review volume, recency and sentiment (see our methodology). Scores last updated 2026-10-22; businesses with few reviews are flagged as low confidence.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to flooring contractor, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DiamondKote Concrete Resurfacing and Epoxy Flooring | 87 | 4.9 (65) | — | Pool decks, epoxy, concrete |
| 2 | New Creation Tile and Marble LLC | 83 | 4.9 (43) | — | Tile floors and showers |
| 3 | Galleria Dream Kitchen and Bath | 81 | 4.9 (18) | — | Kitchen remodel with tile |
| 4 | Custom Hardwood Flooring Plus LLC | 70 | 4.7 (26) | — | Hardwood refinishing, commercial |
| 5 | Custom Concrete Solutions | 69 | 5 (12) | — | Garage and commercial coatings |
| 6 | Home Services at The Home Depot | 62 | 3 (2) | — | Big-box ordering, 7 days |
| 7 | Lombardo&Son Ceramic tile&marble LLC | 59 | 5 (3) | — | Tile and stone setting |
| 8 | Concrete Renovations Inc | 57 | 5 (1) | — | Epoxy floors on a budget |
| 9 | Middletown Ceramic Tile Co | 48 | 4 (1) | — | Checking before you call |
| 10 | Drummond's Carpet Cleaning | 22 | — | — | Carpet cleaning inquiries |
Ranked picks

DiamondKote Concrete Resurfacing and Epoxy Flooring
Why it ranks first
A 4.9 rating across 65 Google reviews gives this the deepest review base on the list, and recent feedback is consistently positive. Pool decks, acid-stained floors and stairs draw the most praise, and owner Mike is often named for staying involved.
Pros
- Pool deck and concrete resurfacing
- Acid staining and decorative overlays
- Punctual crew that leaves the site clean
- Clear communication with owner Mike
Services: Epoxy & Concrete Flooring, Commercial Flooring, Floor Refinishing & Repair

New Creation Tile and Marble LLC
Why it ranks second
With a 4.9 from 43 reviews and high confidence, this tile and marble outfit has a solid, recent track record. Reviewers point to careful tile work, daily cleanup and clear updates from John's crew.
Pros
- Careful, detailed tile installation
- Clean job sites every day
- Clear updates throughout the job
- Covers floors, backsplashes and showers
Watch out: One recent review mentions a cancellation and a surcharge dispute, so get the scope in writing before work starts.
Services: Tile & Stone Flooring, Commercial Flooring

Galleria Dream Kitchen and Bath
Why it ranks third
Rated 4.9 from 18 reviews, so the sample is smaller than the top two but the feedback is strong. It suits homeowners who want design, tile and stone selection, and cabinets handled by one company.
Pros
- Design and remodel under one company
- Responsive project managers
- Custom tile and stone selection
- Courteous, tidy crews
Watch out: Most reviews describe kitchen remodels, so plan on confirming fit for a flooring-only job.
Services: Tile & Stone Flooring, Hardwood Flooring, Laminate & Vinyl Flooring

Custom Hardwood Flooring Plus LLC
Why it ranks fourth
Scores here come from a 4.7 across 26 reviews, with confidence marked low because recent activity is thinner. Newer reviews praise on-time work and a crew that listens, and owner Nick handles concerns directly.
Pros
- Matches stains across existing floors
- Works around tight timelines and weekends
- Residential and commercial projects
- Owner Nick handles concerns directly
Watch out: Some older reviews mention scheduling delays, so confirm your start date up front.
Services: Hardwood Flooring, Carpet Installation, Laminate & Vinyl Flooring, Commercial Flooring

Custom Concrete Solutions
Why it ranks fifth
All 12 reviews are five stars, covering basements, garages, churches and fitness facilities. Certification with five coating systems sets it apart, though the review count keeps confidence low.
Pros
- Certified with PermaCrete, Ashford, EliteCrete, Retroplate and Dur-A-Flex
- Decorative and commercial installs
- Daily progress updates
- Finishes on time
Services: Epoxy & Concrete Flooring, Floor Refinishing & Repair, Commercial Flooring, Hardwood Flooring

Home Services at The Home Depot
Why it ranks sixth
This is the Home Depot service platform, open seven days a week. The score rests on only 2 reviews, one praising a designer and one citing phone access trouble, so treat it as low confidence.
Pros
- Part of the Home Depot network
- Open 7 days
Watch out: Phone access at the Middletown location has been difficult, so consider visiting in person.
Services: Carpet Installation, Laminate & Vinyl Flooring, Commercial Flooring

Lombardo&Son Ceramic tile&marble LLC
Why it ranks seventh
A 5.0 from just 3 reviews, so confidence is low. Those reviews describe precise tile and stone work, punctual arrival and clear cost breakdowns from Joe Lombardo.
Pros
- Master-level tile craftsmanship
- Punctual and reliable
Watch out: Very few reviews so far, so ask for references.
Services: Tile & Stone Flooring

Concrete Renovations Inc
Why it ranks eighth
One five-star review credits Pat with thoughtful system selection and fair pricing. A single review is thin evidence, so the score carries low confidence.
Pros
- Responsive to customer needs
- Competitive pricing on epoxy systems
Watch out: Only one review is on file, so request examples of past work.
Services: Epoxy & Concrete Flooring, Hardwood Flooring, Carpet Installation, Floor Refinishing & Repair

Middletown Ceramic Tile Co
Why it ranks ninth
A 4.0 from a single review about six years old, and the review does not clearly match flooring work. The website lists appliance repair, so confirm services before booking.
Pros
- Local Middletown listing
- Rated 4.0 on one review
Watch out: Confirm that it does flooring work before you call.
Services: Tile & Stone Flooring, Hardwood Flooring

Drummond's Carpet Cleaning
Why it ranks tenth
No Google reviews yet, so the score reflects limited data rather than a verdict. It is listed for carpet cleaning, not installation, and may suit small cleaning jobs.
Pros
- Carpet cleaning focus
- Listed in Middletown
Watch out: No reviews yet, so ask for references.
Services: Carpet Installation
The scoring behind this list
| Signal | Weight |
|---|---|
| Review sentiment | 28% |
| Google rating | 26% |
| Review volume | 20% |
| Profile completeness | 16% |
| Review recency | 10% |
Ranking data checked 2026-10-22 · Full methodology ›